Log in

No account? Create an account
Callidior Quam Ursus Typicus
[Most Recent Entries] [Calendar View] [Friends View]

Thursday, January 18th, 2007

Time Event
Fun court findings: Adultery will get you life in prison in Michigan

Essential breakdown:

Michigan law 1 (old and obscure): Adultery is a felony.
Michigan law 2 (new): sexual penetration of/by another during the course of any other felony is Criminal Sexual Conduct level 1, subject to life imprisonment.
Result: Adultery specifically involving sexual penetration is CSC1, and will land you in jail for life.

For all the people who complain about "activist judges" who "eschew the laws passed by duly elected officials" and "create their own laws," I present what happens when the Court finds a point where the laws become absurd, and do nothing. As the article points out, other courts would throw this out, but Michigan's Supreme Court didn't, stating that the responsibility to fix the law lay in the Legislature, not the Courts.

If we wanted judges to simply apply the laws to the situation at hand, we could create robots plugged into a legal mainframe. But we'd get all the stupid, arcane laws coming up alongside the new, reasonable laws, and people would go to jail for idiotic reasons. Give me an activist judge any day.

<< Previous Day 2007/01/18
Next Day >>
Poore House   About LiveJournal.com